Alma Ata Declaration and Malaria Prevention: Ten Years Narrative Review of landmark Achievement on Use of Insecticide Treated Nets(Itns) Among Pregnant Mothers and Children Under Five in Nigeria

Abstract: Malaria epidemiology in Nigeria is still at a concerning rate. Health promotion is fundamental in primary healthcare (PHC) and one of the components is the prevention of endemic diseases, which include the use of insecticide treated nets (ITNs), provided free and Roll Back Malaria (RBM) programs. The objective of this study is to narratively review the ten years landmark achievement of Alma-Ata declaration on the use of ITNs among pregnant mothers and under-five children between 2009 and 2019 in Nigeria, including the RBM target and geopolitical zones’ performances. Methods: This non-systematic review study selected 50 studies on epidemiology on malaria, PHC, health promotion and Alma-Ata declaration on use of ITNs from literature searched. Search bases included Google Scholar, while inclusion were peer reviewed journals and governmental documents. Results: ITNs ownership and utilization in the geographical zones of Nigeria are unequal since 2010. By 2019, Nigeria household ownership of at least one ITNs was 55%, which is short of the 80% RBM targeted since 10-years ago. Reduction in prevalence of malaria is strongly associated with baseline knowledge of the disease (p < 0.0001); while level of non-utilization of ITNs in 2010 is positively correlated to improvement in ownership in 2019 (p < 0.03). Conclusion: Achievement of Alma-Ata declaration in the availability of ITNs has yet to reach the RBM target and there is indication of backsliding. There is need to reactivate and sustain health promotion programs on ownership and utilization of ITNs at the community level.

Roll Back Malaria (RBM) meeting was convened for African Heads of States in 2000 resulting in the Abuja Declaration, which set targets for major malaria interventions of 80% coverage by 2010 [17,18]. The Abuja Declaration advocated all member states to promote community participation in joint ownership and control of RBM actions, especially as achievements and challenges were been observed [18,19]. Studies report of a rise in use of ITNs in sub-Saharan Africa due to international funding for malaria control among pregnant and children [20,21]. Therefore, the second objective of this landmark review is to articulate how this set target of RBM has been achieved.
It is imperative to note that recognition of the unacceptable mortality and morbidity from malaria in Africa led to the formation of the RBM initiative and Abuja Declaration to halve the burden of malaria and its associated death by 2010. What this review advances is the concept of PHC [7,15,22], with a focus on strategies to sustain malaria prevention. With particular reference to malaria issue in South-South Nigeria, previous review has indicated the need for health promotion among all stakeholders on use of ITNs [13]. In line with the a recent narrative review [5], there are consistent reports that Nigeria contributes the highest proportion of malaria incidents relative to other countries ( Figure 1). Therefore, while there have been several studies on malaria at different localities [6][7][8][9], there is on-going need to evaluate landmark achievements.
Nigeria has six geopolitical zones and while the southern part has climate more amenable to malaria vector, the north is not immune due to multiple environmental factors [11]. It is estimated that only 3% of Nigerians live in the highlands free of malaria. Further, Malaria Indicator Survey (MIS) of 2010 shows that the South West zone with least percentage of ITNs ownership did not have the highest prevalence of malaria among children [10]. Therefore, first of two objectives of this evaluation of achievement in malaria elimination needs to compare geopolitical zones.

Primary health care perspective in use of ITNs to prevent Malaria
The first International Conference on Health Promotion held in-Ottawa in 1986 was built on progress made on PHC, the WHO Targets for Health for All by 2000 and beyond. The conference identified health promotion as a process of enabling people to increase control over, and to improve their health [12]. The declaration defined the components of PHC to include maternal and child health (MCH) as well as health education and control of local diseases, amongst others [4].
Nigeria developed strategic plan to create awareness on prevention of malaria in pregnancy through the use of insecticide treated nets ITNs [14]. Pertinent PHC reforms have occurred over the past three decades including prior to Alma-Ata declaration of PHC in 1978 (Table 1), as Nigeria had set the ball rolling with the implementation of Basic Health Services Scheme (1975)(1976)(1977)(1978)(1979)(1980). In 1992, Nigeria commenced PHC programs in the local government areas, which included the Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI), Integrated Maternal Newborn and Child Health (IMNCH), Maternal Newborn and Child Health Week (MNCHW) and the Im-  2. How has the set target of RBM been achieved?
After excluding article were not peer-reviewed, and not authoritative government documents, the numbers of articles selected from the search themes were: Critical review included descriptive comparisons of data that reported ITNs ownership and prevalence of malaria for 2010 with 2019. Further review was correlation analysis to evaluate associations for improvements in ITNs ownership and reduction on malaria prevalence. Both the correlation evaluation and descriptive comparison were performed using Excel Analysis tool PAK on Microsoft Office 365 ProPlus.

Malaria monitoring outcomes
The prevalence of malaria in Nigeria was reduced from 42% in 2010 to 27% in 2015 and 23% in 2018 [37] and the reduction is due to improvements in possession of ITNs from 8% in 2008 to 69% in 2015. Drop in prevalence of malaria due to effective intervention depicts that Nigeria is in the malaria control phase, but yet to move into elimination phase [38]. Of interest is the observation that the geopolitical zone (South-South), which is one of the zones most prone to malaria has the least percentage ITNs ownership in the urban areas. Among the three southern zones, the South-South appears to have highest proportions of ITNs owners and users, but has also marginally highest in prevalence of malaria.
Southern part of the country has climatic condition more amenable to mosquito survival and hence malaria infestations [11]. The results show that ITNs ownership and utilization of ITNs are unequal between any two zones. While both measures are lower in the south compared to the north (Table 2), improvements are more in the southern ( Figure 2). Comparing the report of 2019 on possession of ITNs with that of 2010 survey in Table 1, it is evident that relative improvement has been unequal ( Figure 2). Further, evaluation of malaria incidence for improvement showed and averaged better in the north (25%) than the south (21.2%). The South West zone showed greatest re-first objective, this review aims to assess how the zones compares with each other in terms of ownership of ITNs.

Health promotion concept: Utilization of ITNs
Health promotion, is the process of raising people control to improve health in their everyday life [12,23]. The Ottawa Charter on health promotion motivated health and social wellbeing of individuals and families [12,24]. Health promotion includes placing health and the agenda of all stakeholders to accept responsibilities on health. Health care responsibilities are divided among individuals, community groups, health professionals, health service institutions and governments [12]. Health promotion concept has been adopted by WHO in the prevention of malaria through promotion of ITNs [25][26][27].
Nigeria has a National Strategic Plan for Malaria Control [8], and one of the plans is to promote the use of ITNs by mass media campaigns [14]. This plan for promotion remains imperative, especially given the impact of perception. Preliminary study from the South-South Nigeria showed that among the households that owned ITNs, about 69% of individual about 69% of individuals did not use ITNs every day [28]. Another report indicated perceptions about chemicals used in treating the ITNs and low risks among adolescents [29].
Similar concerns abound across the tropical countries including Uganda and Kenya [30][31][32][33]. There is a wrong belief that pregnant and non-pregnant adolescents do not need malaria prevention. In addition, health workers have poor communication skills in the communities resulting to low utilization of health facilities and in education on malaria prevention. Therefore, health promotion programs are unequivocally advanced as an option to address the malaria problem [34][35][36]. Hence the third objective is to evaluate the level of correlations in landmark achievements.

Objective of review
This study aims to narratively review the recent ten years' landmark achievement of Alma-Ata declaration on the use of ITNs among pregnant mothers and under-five children between 2009 and 2019 in Nigeria, including the Roll Back Malarial (RBM) target and geopolitical zones' performances vital to health promotion. The main objective is to critically assess and evaluate some available literatures that address the public health issue of ITNs in terms of progress in Nigeria.

Methods
A non-systematic approach was adopted, due to no outcome when all relevant search phrases were applied systematically notably on PubMed. Literature search terms included epidemiology of malaria, primary health care, and health promotion; as well as background trios Alma-Ata declaration, ITNs and Nigeria.
Exclusion and inclusion criteria: The initial search engine for review articles were google scholar and google. Afterwards selection was limited to reputable sources such as peer-reviewed journal articles including from PubMed and World Health Organization as well as governmental materials.  Table 1). The vision was a malaria-free Nigeria, with increase duction in malaria incidence (34.8%) and the South-East and South-South zones performed lowest (Figure 3).

Community based primary health care and RBM target
Alma Ata declaration is a grass root concept of rendering primary health services [15]. To improve health care delivery, Nigeria and other Africa Countries adopted a policy to raise the number of people utilizing ITNs to 60% by 2005 [41]. Despite funding on PHC, government incentives (e.g. provision of basic social amenities) to motivate healthcare, acceptance of job postings to the rural regions is limited. Health promotion, preventive, and PHC interventions are low with the universal health service coverage index [11]. Two key programs that have been developed for PHC involving malaria prevention were:  Alma-Ata declaration on PHC, Support to National Malaria Program (SuNMaP) embarks on mass distribution campaign to support states with supply of ITNs to pregnant women [50].
Government's improvement in PHC program since Alma-Ata declaration has resulted in states receiving support for ITNs, however, some minor discrepancies are reported. For instance, the indication of over 70% of households owning at least one ITNs [8], is uncorroborated with results pre-

Critical review of levels of improvement
A further evaluation of the improvements in ITNs ownership and malaria prevalence among children under 5-years show high levels of correlation. With special focus on South-South Nigeria, it is observed from the report of Okunlola, et al. (2019) that level of improvement in the geopolitical zone on reduction of malaria incidence is better than the country's average ( Figure 5).
Further review of WHO data indicate malaria cases in the country has been 25% in both 2018 and 2019. Reduction in malaria prevalence is more associated with knowledge of incidence created earlier (R = 0.9854; p < 0.0001). Improvement in prevalence is most inversely associated with on-going ownership of ITNs, though no statistical significant difference. Improved in ownership is most inversely associated with existing knowledge of prevalence of malaria, but not statistically significantly different. Percentage of non-utilization of ITNs in 2010 is positively correlated with improvement in ownership of ITNs recorded in 2019 (R = 0.8659; p < 0.03), which implies health promotion improved utilization (Table 3).
ownership and use of ITNs. A significant achievement in control of malaria in Nigeria is the reduction of prevalence of malaria cases from 42% in 2010 to 27.4% in 2015. This success is attributed to increased ownership of ITNs from 2% in 2003 to 8% in 2008 and 69% in 2015. However, there was drop of the ITNs to 61% in 2018 and to 55% in 2019. Indeed, there is evidence of gradual decline instead of improvement (Figure 4). Thus in Nigeria, only an average of 60% households possess ITNs [44][45][46] and this decline in ownership of ITNs in households resonate with the fears of stall in eliminating malaria globally [47]. Report on the use of ITNs in 2019 revealed 55% of households possessing at least one mosquito net for sleeping. This results suggest inadequate intervention to eliminate malaria in Nigeria [40].
Since the Abuja Declaration, there has been progress towards increasing the availability of financial resources for health. The use of community based primary health care (CBPHC) and the use of community health workers (CHWs) in malaria control has averted many child deaths than health facility based services [48,49]. As part of implementing the  Implementation of Millennium Development Goals in Nigeria would fulfill the Alma-Ata declaration on PHC with reduction of MCM through national and international part-nership. Within the period of review, the use of community base PHC and community health workers in malaria control has helped in the mass distribution of nets to rural areas.
These health workers have contributed to improving com-munity knowledge on good health seeking behavior in using ITNs to prevent malaria in pregnant mothers and under five years children. In terms of efficacy measured by reduction in incidence of malaria, this report highlights a 2019 report compared with 2010 ( Figure 3 and Figure 5). Considering 25% report of the WHO for Nigeria in 2018 and 2019, the reports indicate landmark achievement.
While there is achievement in reducing prevalence of malaria in children under 5-years old across the country, the

Discussion
The Declaration of Alma Ata highlighted eight elements that form the basis of comprehensive PHC program interven-tions to achieve health for all. These elements include edu-cation, management and prevention programs for prevailing health problems and methods of preventing and controlling them [51]. Also important are promotion of basic sanitation, proper nutrition and safe water, MCH programs encompass-ing family planning, immunization against major infectious diseases and appropriate provisions for treatment of com-mon diseases and injuries.
The declaration of Alma-Ata was reinforced in Abuja in 2000, by African leaders to halve the burden of malaria and its associated deaths by 2010. One of the first targets was to pro-vide ITNs to pregnant mothers and children under five years to improve the health of the vulnerable population from pre-ventable malaria which causes high rate of deaths. This re-port highlights the failure of landmark agenda that none of the six geo-political zones of Nigeria has achieved the target of 80% ownership of ITNs. Although, there is relative varied improvement across country. Although malaria prevalence  Open Access | Page 199 | reduction in prevalence is not correlated with improvement with ITNs ownership, but seems to trend with actual prevalence ( Figure 4). For instance, in the 2010 report, the South-South zone was not among the top-two with highest ownership of ITNs, but did make up top-to with lowest prevalence of malaria. Based on the 2010 and 2019 reports, evidence is that reduction level in prevalence of malaria across the zones strongly correlates with previous knowledge of prevalence, while non-utilization of the ITNs among owners appear to improve with ownership (Table 3).
Several studies have reported on universal coverage of ITNs distribution and trends in malaria incidence [7,11,36,39] and some have focused on surveillance and factors of utilization [16,38,40,41]. It is known that the RBM has yet to be achieved and this report affirms that Nigeria has 55% household coverage with ITNs and record a decline of malaria incidence since the last 5-years. What is unknown, which this report brings to the fore of discourse is the correlation (and lack thereof) between improvements in ITNs ownership and malaria prevalence with reports of 2010 compared to 2019. The significance to health promotion agenda in pursuit of RBM agenda and PHC improvement is that zones previously doing well in terms of ITNs ownership and malaria prevalence in 2010 have performed less according to 2019 report.

Conclusion
Primary health programs through the influence of political will have gone a long way in near realization of various target toward achieving the Alma-Ata declaration, especially in RBM. The main aim of Alma-Ata declaration is to extend health care services to individuals through their full participation at a cost that the community can afford. Implementation of WHO recommendation to provide ITNs as part of primary health programs has contributed to the reduction of MCH mortality associated with malaria. Achievement of Alma-Ata declaration in terms of RBM is declining; and geo-political zones with previous admirable records are currently less performing. Result shows that improvement in malaria prevalence is associated with baseline knowledge of the situation. Further, reduction in malaria disease level is not really correlated with ITNs ownership, but seems to trend with baseline knowledge of prevalence. Recommendation is therefore made that various levels of government should review their PHC programs. Community based awareness programs to change the attitude of households in the use of ITNs need to be enhanced.